When Jurgen Klopp and Pep Guardiola had their very first meeting in 2013, neither could have predicted their rivalry would span two countries. This Klopp versus Guardiola is dubbed “The new Ferguson vs Wenger with less aggro” by The Sun, and we can’t disagree.
These are two managers who couldn’t be more different. Klopp is a charismatic, often animated manager on the touchline and during press conferences. On the other hand, Pep is the very definition of cool, calm and collected.
Pep has called their relationship a “beautiful rivalry.” This is very different from the rivalry between Alex Ferguson and Arsene Wenger, which was anything but beautiful.
As the football world is obsessed with comparison, for sure, these two great managers of their generation have been pitted against each other. Here, we take a look at various arguments to figure out who the better coach is.
Klopp vs Guardiola -Tactical Philosophy
In terms of tactical philosophy, the Klopp vs Guardiola debate has two distinctly opposite philosophies.
Pep is a disciple of Johann Cryuff, and he has adopted his style as a coach popularly known as “Tiki-Taka”. It is a disciplined playing style which focuses on possession and aggressive pressing off the ball.
His philosophy has seen him adopt a variety of formations over the years, including the 3-4-3. However, his preferred formation has always been 4-3-3. This style requires midfielders that are very comfortable on the ball.
Since his arrival in the Premier League, he has had to tweak his style due to the madness of the league. His abilities as a manager have led him to unprecedented success in all three clubs he has managed including a staggering 14 trophies at Barcelona in 4 years.
Pep is a master tinkerer, and he is a nightmare for FPL players.
Klopp, on the other hand, favours counterattacking and high pressing football popularly known as “Gengenpressing.” Several teams have tried to adopt this style, but the most successful implementation have come from Klopp’s sides.
The gengenpress is a demanding style that requires pacey players who can press the ball from the opposition half. This led him to success with Borussia Dortmund dominating Bayern Munich for two years in Germany.
Like Pep, he has had to tweak his style a bit in England to incorporate possession football. While he is a great tactician, he hasn’t changed his formation a lot over the years, favouring a 4-3-3. However, he has used 4-2-3-1, 3-5-2 and a 4-2-4.
One thing that makes Klopp unique is how he endears himself into the hearts of not only his players but his fans and rivals with his wide grin.
Klopp vs Guardiola – Head to Head
This is pretty straightforward. Klopp and Pep have faced each other 17 times over the years. Klopp has a slight Klopp vs Guardiola edge with 8 wins compared to Pep’s 7.
Their very first meeting came in the 2013/14 season in the German Super Cup match between Klopp’s Dortmund and Pep’s Bayern. Klopp came out tops in that one with a 4-2 victory. Their most recent meeting came in Man city’s triumph in the 2019 Community Shield.
This close head-to-head battle is one of the reasons their rivalry has become intriguing. Both managers usually have to be more conservative in their styles when facing each other. This shows the amount of respect they have for each other.
If you’re good with maths, this will interest you. Pep has a 72% career win ratio, 12% of his career losses have come from Klopp alone. The German is the only manager he has faced five times or more that has a winning record on him.
With just a little over ten years in management (including a one-year sabbatical), Pep’s trophy haul is staggering! His most recent win came in the 2019 Community Shield win against Liverpool.
That win took his trophy tally to 27! That’s an average of about 2.7 trophies every year. His haul of 14 trophies in Barcelona is a record for the club by a single manager.
When compared to the Spaniard, Klopp’s trophy haul of just seven seems meagre. But when you compare the calibre of teams the German has managed, it’s quite impressive.
He was able to guide Dortmund to back to back league wins against almighty Bayern. His most recent success came in the victory against Chelsea in the 2019 UEFA Super Cup.
Both managers are very different in style and calibre of teams they’ve managed. They are, however, respected by their peers and adored by fans all over the world.
They have turned several players they managed into world-class players. Klopp has Mané, an FPL favourite and Salah, Pep has De Bruyne and Sterling.
However, based on the arguments that have been made for both coaches, some may say that Pep Guardiola wins the Klopp vs Guardiola rivalry.
Many would argue that Klopp wins since he has managed clubs with tighter budgets compared to Pep.
Pep’s teams dominate whatever league he is in, imposing his style and authority. His trophy cabinet is already spilling over and would likely continue to increase.
Klopp is also impressive. His manic style of football is a joy to watch for the modern football fan. Who would you rather pick in the Klopp vs Guardiola saga? Let us know in the comments below.
- Did you know Klopp retired as Mainz 05 record goalscorer despite being a defender? Of course, you didn’t! He’s 3rd on the list now.
- Did you know Pep holds the record for most consecutive wins in La Liga, Bundesliga and EPL?
I love Crossandnod!!!
We love you too ❤
Is Pep really Calm??? I doubt this… He’s always ready to lash out…
He is calm most times, that’s fine
Omo, it’s Pep o. I’m hoping Manchester United will even steal him in the nearest future. That guy’s football is just too amazing ☺️
Even Pep can’t save United. He would always be compared to Fergie, those are shoes too big for any manager to fill
I read the article word for word! Nice one Balogun
I’d choose Klopp for his charisma but Pep for his tactics
Both are really great managers
Beautiful article. I’d choose Klopp cause of his style of play and charisma
His style is quite infectious
If Pep had taken over teams Klopp has managed and in their situation,I would have rated him but going to structured clubs, with no crisis, and heavy transfer budgets and doing the norm is not special please. Klopp over Pep any day and any time
@Temidire Sampam has a point!
This is a wonderful point. But as stated in the article, in the hand of lesser managers, many would not do as well as Pep in his position. He has taken every team he coached to unprecedented levels of success, especially in the league. That’s very impressive. Then, it is hard to argue that Klopp has had to take the more difficult route to success
This article is a brilliant basis for a much wider argument. Klopp and Pep are both the present and the future, they may look like they have different approaches to football but fundamentally they are the same. Both make use of “cores” (Ederson/Fernadinho/Jesus- Allison/Fabinho/Firmino), something other managers don’t get yet and it cannot be a coincidence that they are both Brazillian cores. They both know something others do not and its showing. All competitions last year were riddled with handprints of Klopp and Pep. Copa America(Jesus), Afcon(Mahrez), UNL(Silva).This article means more…
Hey Alcibaides, thank you for your insightful comments. Those two are way ahead of the pack! Don’t forget to come back again for premium football content.
Really insightful comment Alcibaides. You know your stuff. Other managers need to pick up a thing or two from these great coaches. They consistently evolve their styles and would continue to dominate the sport
First of all, it’s “gegenpressing” not “gengenpressing”.
Secondly, I don’t think Pep made KDB world class. And even if he did, I’d say Klopp has the advantage since from the players we see them turning world class, Klopp has the advantage because he actually bought those players while Pep inherited his.
Pep is awesomely good, I prefer Klopp though.
Thanks for catching the error
Good write-up too though
Hmm… Your write up is getting better and better. With the facts and figures, as potrayed by the stats which showed that Klopp is better than Pep head-to-head, coupled with the fact that Klopp operates on a tight budget.
I’d go for Klopp any day. He guarantees a full stadium… Know what I mean?
Well said. I see what you did there?.
It’s funny how City never manage to fill up the Emptihad considering the brand of football they play.
Lool nice one.